How to Tell if Someone is Toxic: Signs to Watch for and How to Respond with Grace

In our relationships, we often find ourselves wondering whether someone in our life is bringing us closer to peace and fulfilment, or if they are pulling us away from those things. One of the ways we can discern this is by considering whether a relationship is toxic. A toxic relationship can deeply affect our emotional, mental, and even spiritual well-being. As Christians, we are called to love, forgive, and extend grace. However, it’s also vital to recognize when someone’s behaviour is unhealthy and seek God’s wisdom on how to respond with care and boundaries.

Here are a few signs that someone might be toxic and what you can do about it.

1. Constant Negativity or Criticism

Toxic individuals often bring a cloud of negativity wherever they go. If you find that someone is constantly criticizing you or others, it could be a sign of underlying toxicity. Proverbs 18:21 reminds us, "The tongue has the power of life and death," meaning that words have the potential to uplift or destroy. Someone who consistently uses words to tear down rather than build up may be causing emotional harm.

In such cases, it’s important to protect your heart (Proverbs 4:23) while gently confronting the person, in love, about their behaviour. If their response is defensive or dismissive, it may be necessary to distance yourself for your well-being.

2. Manipulation and Control

A toxic person often tries to manipulate situations or exert control over others to get their way. This can look like guilt-tripping, gaslighting (making you question your reality), or using emotional outbursts to make you comply with their wishes.

In 2 Timothy 1:7, Paul reminds us that "God has not given us a spirit of fear, but of power, love, and a sound mind." Manipulation is often rooted in fear—either fear of losing control or fear of rejection. If someone in your life consistently causes you to feel fear or anxiety about their reactions, it’s important to recognize that this isn't a relationship built on love or mutual respect.

3. Lack of Accountability

We all make mistakes, but a toxic person often refuses to take responsibility for their actions. Instead, they may blame others or act as if nothing is ever their fault. A relationship where someone is unwilling to admit when they’re wrong can create emotional exhaustion and disillusionment.

Jesus teaches us in Matthew 18:15-17 how to address conflict in a healthy way. If someone wrongs you, first go to them privately and share your concerns. If they are unwilling to listen or acknowledge their behaviour, it may be time to reconsider how much access they have to your life. Setting boundaries does not mean cutting off love or forgiveness, but it does mean protecting yourself from harm.

4. Isolation

Toxic individuals often try to isolate you from friends, family, or even your church community. This form of control can make you feel dependent on them for approval or emotional support, weakening your connections to others who love and care for you.

Hebrews 10:24-25 encourages us to "consider how we may spur one another on toward love and good deeds, not giving up meeting together." Community is important, and a healthy relationship should encourage, not discourage, your connection to others. If someone is isolating you, it’s important to seek help from trusted people in your life or a spiritual mentor.

5. Disrespecting Your Boundaries

Healthy relationships respect boundaries—emotional, spiritual, and physical. Toxic people often disregard those boundaries, whether by making hurtful comments, invading your personal space, or overstepping limits you’ve set. They may use guilt, anger, or manipulation to convince you to bend your boundaries.

James 1:19 tells us, "Everyone should be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to become angry." A person who respects you will take the time to listen and respect your wishes. If someone is repeatedly crossing your boundaries, it’s important to be firm in communicating them and, if necessary, enforcing consequences for when those boundaries are ignored.

How to Respond with Grace and Love

It’s natural to feel torn between wanting to extend grace and wanting to protect yourself. As Christians, we’re called to love our neighbour as ourselves (Mark 12:31), but that doesn’t mean tolerating harmful behaviour. Loving someone may involve setting firm boundaries, walking away from toxic situations, or seeking professional help through counselling or pastoral care.

• Pray for Wisdom: James 1:5 assures us that if we ask God for wisdom, He will give it generously. When navigating a toxic relationship, prayer can help you discern the right path.

• Forgive, but Protect Your Heart: Forgiveness is a key part of the Christian life (Matthew 6:14-15), but forgiveness does not mean allowing someone to continue to hurt you. You can forgive while also creating distance or enforcing boundaries for your protection.

• Seek Support: Lean on your church community, friends, or even a Christian counsellor to help you process your feelings and take steps toward healing. We were never meant to carry these burdens alone (Galatians 6:2).

A Journey of Healing

Recognizing a toxic relationship is the first step in protecting your emotional, mental, and spiritual health. As you navigate these challenges, remember that God sees your pain and walks with you through it. He desires peace and wholeness for your relationships (Colossians 3:15). While we are called to love others, we are also called to care for ourselves and seek His guidance in dealing with difficult situations.

If you find yourself in a toxic relationship, know that there is hope for healing—both for yourself and potentially for the other person. With God’s wisdom and the support of a caring community, you can take steps toward a healthier and more peaceful life.

Ready to Take Your Healing to the Next Level?

Apply to my Tend to Your Garden coaching program—it's completely free to apply and the first step toward reclaiming your peace and wholeness. Start your journey today!"

Scripture to Meditate On:
“Above all, love each other deeply, because love covers over a multitude of sins.” — 1 Peter 4:8